New York Cheesecake $17.00
North Babylon & Lindenhurst, Long Island
The Ultimate Bakery
Custom cakes, kosher Italian and French pastries. Same family since 1991.
Bring us your idea, or a picture of the cake you have in mind. We'll hand-pipe it in the shop, so the cake at your party looks the way you pictured it, or better.
Kosher
Custom cakes hand-piped to orderItalian & French pastry caseNorth Babylon & Lindenhurst
Custom cakes
Cakes built from your picture
Show us an idea, or a photo of the cake you have in mind, and the team will sit with you, design it, and craft every detail in the shop, so the cake at your party looks the way you pictured it, or better.
“I couldn't be happier with the cake I ordered for my engagement party. It came out absolutely perfect, honestly even better than I imagined. The design was flawless, the details were stunning, and the taste was out of this world.”
— Stephanie, on her engagement cake Engagement Custom engagement cakes See how to order
Birthday Birthday cakes See how to order
Character & Kids Character cakes See how to order
Wedding Tiered wedding cakes See how to order
Seasonal Seasonal & holiday cakes See how to order
How it works
How to Order a Custom Cake
Bring the picture. We pipe it by hand.
1
Share your idea
Share your idea, or a photo of the cake you have in mind, and the team will sit with you to design it.
2
We make it by hand
Every custom cake is hand-piped in the shop, then it's ready for you to pick up for your celebration.
3
Ready for your day
Call ahead to talk through timing for your date.
The family behind the counter
Still hand-piped, one at a time
This is still a family bakery, not a franchise. The people behind the counter grew up in this business, and they still make everything the same careful way they always have.
A clean shop and a warm counter
Customers come back for how the shop feels as much as what's in the case, clean, well kept, and staffed by people who are genuinely glad to see you.
“Excellent bakery. Great service and clean. Delicious, and so many selections. The prices are very fair.”— Karin
Worth the price for the quality
Yes, the cakes and pastries here cost more than a grocery store shelf, and regulars will tell you the quality earns it every time.
“The desserts are delicious, so dig deep into your pockets and enjoy.”— David
People notice the details, the piped borders, the not-too-sweet cannoli filling, the case that's stocked for every kind of celebration. Read what regulars say for themselves on Google and Facebook.
Visit
Two Locations on Long Island
The original shop sits in La Grande Plaza on Deer Park Avenue in North Babylon, and a second location has opened in Lindenhurst. Stop in, call, or bring your cake idea to either counter.
North Babylon
1350 Deer Park Ave #26, North Babylon, NY 11703
La Grande Plaza, Deer Park Avenue
Lindenhurst
A second location on Long Island
Call for the Lindenhurst address and hours before you head over.
Hours: Open daily, 8am to 7pm, according to their Instagram. Google doesn't list hours yet, so call ahead to confirm before a special trip.
Ready to Order Your Cake?
Tell us what you're celebrating, share your idea or a picture, and we'll design it with you and make it to order in the shop. Or stop by for cannoli, cookies, or a cheesecake, no occasion required.
Or send your idea